Evaluating Rental Properties: Why, How + 5 Tips


Real estate investors place a different value on a rental property than a typical homeowner would. 

Investors purchase rental properties not only to improve living conditions for potential tenants but also to generate cash flow and increase equity through the market and property appreciation. 

Many people decide to invest in rental properties to create a stream of passive income. It is a great way to diversify your sources of income and build wealth for future generations, however, before you invest in any property, you need to understand that evaluating rental properties requires careful consideration and analysis to ensure a successful investment. 

In this article, we will explore the importance of evaluating rental properties, discuss the process of evaluating properties, and provide useful tips to help you make informed decisions when considering potential rental properties.

Why Evaluate Rental Properties?


Evaluating rental properties is a critical step in the process of investing in real estate. You cannot be sure investing in a rental property will be profitable until you do a full evaluation, you can’t rely on instincts, and if not, you risk setting yourself up for a major loss. 

Evaluating rental properties involves carefully evaluating a property’s various components to decide whether it would be a good investment and to make informed decisions. 

Some reasons why evaluating rental properties is important include:

1. Risk Assessment

Investment generally comes with risks that vary depending on the type of investment. Before you decide to invest, you can determine the degree of investment risk by evaluating rental properties. 

This will help you make informed decisions, as investing in real estate carries inherent risks, including varying economic situations, shifting market dynamics, and unforeseen costs. 

You can detect and evaluate potential hazards by evaluating a rental property, which will help you make smart investment decisions and reduce those risks as much as you can. You would also be able to safeguard your investment funds and reduce potential losses.

2. Profitability Analysis

Evaluating rental properties helps you determine the profitability and potential for income of the property in question. 

Before you decide to invest in a rental property, you need to assess whether the property corresponds with your investment objectives and goals. It is essential to consider its financial characteristics. 

By evaluating rental properties, you can also determine the estimated return on investment (ROI) by examining variables including rental rates, operational costs, vacancy rates, and market demand. 

This evaluation enables you to determine whether the rental property can bring in enough revenue from rentals to pay the bills and provide a positive cash flow. 

It also aids in locating properties with the potential for capital growth and long-term value.

3. Market Analysis

Evaluating rental properties involves performing an exhaustive market analysis. This means investigating and comprehending the characteristics of the neighborhood rental market, including rental rates, vacancy rates, and rental trends. 

By researching the market, you can gauge the local demand for rental properties and spot any new trends that might have an impact on rental income. 

By determining if the rental revenue is competitive and sustainable, you can make sure that your investment will continue to be lucrative over time.

4. Property Condition Assessment

Evaluating rental properties allows you to perform an exhaustive evaluation of the property’s state. 

This includes looking over maintenance logs, inspecting the actual building, and assessing any prospective repair or remodeling requirements. 

With this, you can determine the costs of upkeep and improvements by evaluating the state of the property. 

This evaluation helps you avoid unforeseen costs and ensures that the property is in a desirable state to attract great tenants and maintain its value.

5. Investment Alignment

By evaluating rental properties, you can ensure that the investment is in line with your investment strategies and objectives. 

Whether it’s earning passive income, diversifying their holdings, or accumulating long-term wealth, every investor has distinct objectives. 

See also  6 Simple Ways To Invest In Real Estate In Nigeria: A Guide

You can assess how well a property fits into your investment strategy. Whether an investment aligns with your goals and financial objectives will affect your investment decisions positively or negatively.

How to Evaluate Rental Properties


1. The Sales Comparison Approach 

One of the methods for evaluating rental properties is the sales comparison approach (SCA). It is a well-known approach often used by appraisers, real estate agents, and real estate investors when evaluating homes.

The sales comparison approach involves comparing the values of similar properties that have recently been sold or rented in the area. 

Most investors will want to see an SCA over a long period of time to identify any potential emerging trends.

The SCA uses qualities or attributes to determine a relative market value. Any features that make a property distinctive and remarkable may be taken into consideration when determining these values, including the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, garages and/or drives, pools, decks, and fireplaces.

All investors can use price per square foot as a standard and simple criteria when evaluating rental properties, to determine the value of their property. 

Practically speaking, valuing a home as an investment or a primary residence depends on the sales comparison approach. 

A 1,500-square-foot rental property, for instance, would be valued between $225,000 and $240,000 if five comparable homes with similar features as the rental property previously sold for between $150 and $160 per square foot.

Due to its enormous scope, the SCA is only meant to offer a general idea. It can only be used to compare your investment property with other properties with similar features. 

Comparing two properties with identical square footage and completely different features won’t be useful.

2. The Income Approach

One of the main factors motivating an investor to purchase a rental property is the expected net operating income. 

Therefore, taking into account both past and future income in addition to other valuation methods when evaluating rental properties can help you make smart investment decisions.

The income approach centers around how much income a rental property would be able to generate in relation to the initial investment. 

The income approach is often used for commercial real estate investing, but it can be useful for other types of real estate investments.

A vital component of the income approach is the annual capitalization rate of an investment. This rate is calculated by dividing the predicted yearly income from the gross rent multiplier by the property’s current value. 

The basic monthly rent as well as any other income sources, including rent, water income, and private parking revenue, are all included in the overall annual income for a property. 

Charges for things like leasing, maintenance, repairs, property taxes, and insurance are included in operating expenses.

This means that if an office building costs $120,000 to buy and the anticipated monthly income from rent is $1,200, the predicted annual capitalization rate is 14,400 ($1,200 x 12 months) or $120,000 = 0.12 or 12%. 

This is a relatively simplified model with few underlying assumptions. There are probably interest costs associated with a mortgage.

 Additionally, five years from now, prospective rental incomes can be worth more or less than they are right now.

The concept of the net present value of money is well-known to investors. This idea is often referred to as “discounted cash flow when it comes to real estate. 

Future funds are provided in discounted terms to reflect the risk of inflation and deflation that they are exposed to.

3. The Capital Asset Pricing Model

The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) is a more thorough technique for evaluating rental properties. 

It is one of the most complex methods of evaluating rental properties because it covers risk and opportunity costs as they relate to real estate investing.

When evaluating rental properties, the capital asset pricing model considers several variables, including the property’s age, condition, location, neighborhood ranking, operational costs, projected rental income, and eventual net cash flow. 

See also  How To Earn Passive Income With Airbnb In Real Estate

The capital asset pricing model examines the possible return on investment (ROI) received from rental income and compares it with other risk-free assets like US Treasury bonds or other real estate investments like real estate investment trusts (REITs).

In other words, it doesn’t make financial sense to take on the risk of rental property if the projected return on a risk-free or guaranteed investment exceeds the possible ROI from rental revenue. 

The CAPM takes into account the dangers that come with renting out real estate by calculating risk.

According to CAPM theory, the only way a real estate investor can make more money is by taking on more risk in exchange for the possibility of greater gain. 

Some real estate investors, meanwhile, might counter that it’s actually possible to locate a rental property that offers a healthy balance of risk and profit.

4. The Cost Approach

The cost approach is a method of evaluating rental properties that focuses on the notion that a real estate investor will not pay more for a resale property than it would cost to build the same home from the ground up. 

This method states that a piece of property is only worth what it can be reasonably utilized for. 

It is calculated by adding the land value and the value of any improvements that have been depreciated.

Appraisers that frequently use this method for valuing real estate advocate using the highest and best use of the property to summarize the cost approach to real estate. 

It is commonly used as a benchmark for valuing undeveloped land.

For instance, if you are an apartment developer wanting to buy three acres of land in a desolate area to build condominiums, the value of the land will be determined by its best use. 

Property zoning is another best-use argument. The value of the potential land is diminished if it is not designated for residential use because rezoning will cost the developer a lot of money. 

This method is the least reliable for older homes and the most reliable when applied to newer buildings. When examining specific usage properties, it is typically the only method that is trustworthy. 

5. Gross Rent Multiplier Approach

A rental property’s worth is determined by the gross rent multiplier (GRM) approach using the annual rent an investor is likely to receive. 

It is a quick and simple method of determining whether a property is worthwhile for an investment. 

This should be taken with a grain of salt since it doesn’t account for any taxes, insurance, utilities, or other costs related to the property. 

It just allows investors to get an approximate sense of how long it would take to pay off a rental property using the gross cash flow generated.

The gross rent multiplier approach differs from the income strategy in that it uses gross rent as its cap rate rather than net operating income. 

You simply divide the current market value or purchase price of the property by the gross yearly rental income to determine GRM.

The cap rate for the gross rent multiplier is more than one, but the cap rate for the income approach is expressed as a percentage. 

Even though a rental property could have a lower GRM and hence seem to have more value to an investor, it might also need more frequent upkeep or costly capital repairs, such as a new roof or HVAC system.

Tips for Evaluating Rental Properties 


Building a successful and productive rental portfolio requires a long-term commitment, which is why reviewing and assessing properties will be helpful. 

By following these tips, you can thoroughly evaluate rental properties and make informed investment decisions that align with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

1. Conduct Thorough Research

When evaluating rental properties, you must perform thorough research to find out as much about the property as you can. 

See also  Flipping Houses In Georgia: All You Need To Know (2023)

Gather all pertinent information about the property, such as rental history, financial information, tax documents, and any zoning or legal restrictions that may or may not be in place. 

To ensure you have a complete understanding of the property’s history and current condition, review leases, property documents, and inspection reports.

As a potential investor, researching rental markets and properties is an important step to take before investing in rental properties

This helps you make informed decisions on what properties to invest in.

2. Seek Professional Advice

Consider seeking advice from experts who focus on real estate and rental property investing. 

You can build a team of professionals that can offer insightful opinions and direction throughout the review process. 

An ideal team would include real estate brokers, property managers, and financial consultants. 

Their knowledge can assist you in making wise choices and seeing possibilities or risks you may have otherwise missed.

Each professional brings a unique skill set and expertise to the table, and working with them can help in properly evaluating rental properties. 

However, you must choose professionals with experience in the rental property market and a proven track record of success.

3. Use The One Percent Rule

If you have been in the real estate industry for a while, then you have probably heard about the one percent rule. 

It is a smart and easy way to determine if the rental property’s monthly rent will be greater than the monthly mortgage payment. 

You can use this straightforward calculation to determine whether a potential rental property will bring in money if you’re evaluating rental properties. 

Properties that comply with the one percent rule will generate monthly rents that equal at least one percent of the asking price. Included in that are the fixes required to have the place ready for rental. 

You could consider it a prerequisite and continue to the next prospective listing if the property doesn’t yield the desired profit. 

Alternatively, you could ask for a real estate pro forma, which will provide you with a breakdown of the property’s most recent earnings and expenses.

4. Factor In Risk Management

Determine and evaluate any possible hazards related to the investment in rental property. Think about how changes in local laws or market conditions, potential vacancies, unforeseen repairs, or unanticipated repairs could influence your investment. 

To reduce risks and safeguard your investment, create backup plans and set aside money for unforeseen costs.

5. Perform Cash Flow Analysis

To perform a cash flow analysis, you need to calculate the property’s prospective income and expenses. 

Using market rates and occupancy rates, determine the estimated rental income. 

Subtract charges such as real estate taxes, insurance, upkeep, management fees, and mortgage payments (if applicable). 

Make sure that once all costs are taken into account, the property generates a positive cash flow.

If you borrowed money, you could decide on a fair rent that would provide monthly cash flow that would aid in paying off your debt and making a profit. 

Additionally, if you’re new to real estate, you should understand your numbers and accurately estimate the expenses that will arise during the first few months of your rental business to determine how well you’re doing as a landlord. 


In conclusion, evaluating rental properties is a crucial step in making smart investment choices. 

You can efficiently evaluate the practicality, profitability, and potential of rental properties by understanding the importance of property evaluations and following an organized evaluation method.

How To Invest In Real Estate In Nigeria: A Complete Guide

20 Incredible Reasons Why You Should Invest In A Fixer-Upper

Cash Offer In Real Estate: Meaning, Pros, Cons & How To Get

Ultimate Guide To Staging A Home + 20 Easy Tips

Flipping Houses In New York: A Complete Guide (2023)

Flipping Houses In Utah: How and 8 Quick Tips

Top 20 Companies That Buy Houses For Cash